Francis I'm in the same boat as you. No matter how many times I get dumped by my girl, she always comes back and never dates other men. I think I've been dumped like 50 times. Lost track.
I like to think that the more a girl hates you, the more proof of her love. I often think, "That's it, I'm not gonna deal with this crap anymore," but she always comes back with a sweet voice and apologizes. I put up with it because she's beautiful, and I think, "Well, it doesn't really bother me that much..." But I have no idea how I could make a marriage work with her. So we remain in perpetual limbo.
I think you're right, she loved me so much that I had to be perfect. But looking back on things now it was more like maybe she loved herself and I was what she wanted so she needed it to be perfect for herself nothing was ever going to be good enough. I'm not perfect and I never will be as much as I tried to be for her, it wore me down. I wanted to spend the rest of my life with this woman I was completely devoted to her more than I have ever been to anyone or anything, I know that goes against much of the thinking here but this was it for me I was happy to make her happy and I always tried to do anything I can to show her my devotion and make her happy. But I was actually the one that would leave her over these blowups and I made sure she was the one to come back to me, I wouldn't go back to her. Not because I didn't want her back I was absolutely miserable without her but I stayed strong because I didn't want to reward bad behavior, I needed her to learn that it wasn't okay to behave this way with the man who has devoted everything to you.
It was like dealing with a spoiled entitled child, it didn't matter how much accumulation of good there was, there was no benefit of the doubt or understanding, as soon as she didn't get things exactly the way she wanted I was a cheater, a liar and the devil. I don't say that to insult her she isn't deserving of insults, people just are who they are she's not a bad person by any means.
She's not young and she's not an unintelligent person I figured over time she would learn that this isn't like before, she would learn that this man has devoted his entire life to her and I don't need to be upset over small things because he'll always give me what I want because he's going to stand by me forever. It just never happened, mind you the only thing I ever asked of her was to respect that she's in a committed relationship and change the way she does things and consider me in those things she does and it was always a fight to get that because in her mind everything was always positive and she was doing no wrong, all that self help garbage.
It got worse the last couple months because I was just defeated as I knew no matter what I did I was on borrowed time until the next blowup over nothing and then I would get really defensive over anything because I felt like I had to constantly protect myself from her wrath. I was starting to withdraw because it was constant anxiety over it and she noticed that and that made her just go at me harder. A lot of times she didn't realize what she was saying or doing, I used to tell her a lot "you need to think about the things you say and do" because I knew it wasn't malicious it was just that self help crap where even something bad was positive in her head, took me a while to figure that out I was confused for a long time how she thought some things were okay to say and do but in her head they were different than the reality of them. I'm not a negative person by any means but she turned me into one just because I would fall in line with her being negative towards me, then as I said before at the drop of a hat everything is positive again, it was maddening I don't function that way I need a resolution and a lesson learned not just ignore it because you want your toy back and then it happens all over again next week, nothing learned.
I love the girl I don't want to move on but I have to I really have no choice, look I'm not desperate and I'm not ashamed to say that girls fawn all over me, marriage material girls, I won't even talk about what the lower class girls do haha. The reason why this hurts is because I gave this girl all of me and it was worthless, I take nothing from it. At least with past relationships I learned lessons but here it's nothing I just wasted my time and emotions for someone who it was never going to be good enough for. There were other issues too, she's very entrenched into her life and I don't have any interest in living the way she lives but I was the one expected to come half way she couldn't come half way just because of what her life is. But I did that and it just wasn't enough, nothing was going to be enough again it was like a child that didn't get what they wanted that day it didn't matter that they got everything all the other days.
I never cheated never even thought about cheating I would never have done that to her as much as she accused me of it, I never told her "no" to anything that would make her happy even if it was something I didn't want, I never asked anything unreasonable or crazy things like I said what I asked for was to respect our relationship. The most I ever did wrong was having responsibilities that SOMETIMES I couldn't neglect for her, many times I did neglect them and that apparently was just unforgivable no matter how much logic or explanation I provided. I didn't want anyone or anything but her, again this was going to be my wife or so I thought. My wife is the queen of my earth but apparently that just wasn't good enough.
I've respectfully asked her not to contact me again and she has respected that for the most part. I'm miserable right now over her and I'm actually going through the most difficult thing I've ever faced in my life business wise and I'm kinda just on my own. But it's for the best honestly the best for both us, she needs someone different from me I don't fit into her life or how she does things as much as I tried. It will fade and I will be okay one day soon I won't care about any of this, believe me I don't need any pity you can save that for the weak I'm just venting it feels good to put this into words. Life is good and I live a great life surrounded by people enamored with me, just have to stay strong and realize I can't change it, which I have. Mind you this is my perspective, I'm sure if you spoke with her she has a completely different one so it would have never changed she proved that many times I had no choice but to let it all go as much as it didn't have to be that way and I didn't want it that way.
To quote P. Diddy : "Time to move on, time to be strong.....don't stop now straight to the top now". Sorry had to throw that in haha.