Is secular dating/game over after online dating apps?

After my last relationship ended, I started using the apps again. My profile is basically the same, I added a few new pictures that I think were better than the ones I replaced.

My activity level was probably 10-20% of what it was before. And I wasn't getting a whole lot of action before my last relationship. I deleted most the apps and kept the Christian one, where as least I've had a few matches of medium-quality women (and most of them have less communication skills than a pigeon). Had one good match of a pretty, Orthodox woman and then she deleted me a day after expressing interest, which was disappointing.

It's hard not to get despondent about things sometimes. I am just trying to be comfortable by myself and trust God. When I was younger, I never worried about finding someone, but as I get older, I feel like it will get harder to marry a quality woman. I'm in my mid 30s and feel comfortable I could get a nice 20-something year old woman, but when I turn 40 I feel like I will be "too old" for most of them. Unlike some people on this forum, I think some women who are 30s (especially early 30s) can be decent prospects (some women have trouble finding good men too, and men can be deceptive just like women can) but I don't want to utilize that option until I am older.
 
After my last relationship ended, I started using the apps again. My profile is basically the same, I added a few new pictures that I think were better than the ones I replaced.

My activity level was probably 10-20% of what it was before. And I wasn't getting a whole lot of action before my last relationship. I deleted most the apps and kept the Christian one, where as least I've had a few matches of medium-quality women (and most of them have less communication skills than a pigeon). Had one good match of a pretty, Orthodox woman and then she deleted me a day after expressing interest, which was disappointing.

It's hard not to get despondent about things sometimes. I am just trying to be comfortable by myself and trust God. When I was younger, I never worried about finding someone, but as I get older, I feel like it will get harder to marry a quality woman. I'm in my mid 30s and feel comfortable I could get a nice 20-something year old woman, but when I turn 40 I feel like I will be "too old" for most of them. Unlike some people on this forum, I think some women who are 30s (especially early 30s) can be decent prospects (some women have trouble finding good men too, and men can be deceptive just like women can) but I don't want to utilize that option until I am older.

Nice post. It's good to read about some of our fellow CIK members' real experiences. Online forums seem to inevitably facilitate endless complaining, and it takes ongoing discipline to focus on hope and action over venting and rumination.

I know you didn't ask a question, so I'm unsure if you're seeking advice in addition to sharing your experiences. If you have any specific questions, fire away. In the meantime, since you seem open to introspection, here are some thoughts to consider.

Understanding yourself and the world
  • Well done for getting back out there and trying again after your relationship ended. It can take some time (months to years) to fully recover, so it's good to see you are resilient and trying again.
  • Online dating is tough, so you need to be not just tougher, but also smarter, and this means having a clear, definable strategy.
  • It's encouraging that you seem self-aware and realistic about your dating prospects as it relates to age. Let's be real. Men have a "wall" -- it just doesn't hit as hard or fast as for women. Nowhere is this more evident than online. Compared to avenues that involve in-person interaction, online dating makes age gaps a huge barrier to meeting up. This is because, if a woman sets her limit to just 1 year below your age, you'll NEVER match with her. If you are 35+ let alone 40+, merely matching with attractive women in their early to mid 20s online (assuming they are trad, not gold diggers etc) is going to be highly unlikely.
  • In the eyes of many women in their mid-late 20s, the age around mid-30s is the key time when men change from being "an option" vs "not an option". Why? Because 33 is linked to "a bit past 30", whereas 37 is associated with "almost 40". Consider how your precise age is viewed within this framework.
  • For a man in his mid-late 30s, some women in their late 20s and even early 30s (assuming they haven't gone through a ho3 phase, don't have an attachment disorder etc) can be a suitable prospect for marriage/children. This is because they are likely to be more ready to fully commit, get married, and prepare for having children compared to women in their early 20s or even mid 20s. Note: This is a broad statement about women that does not address the context of a church community, the theoretical ideal age of early-mid 20s for getting together, etc.
Moving forward with action

Content-wise, this thread seems like a dupe of the thread 'Are dating apps in any way good for Christians?' In that thread, I wrote a clear action plan for Christrian men navigating the modern dating market here.

Most of my advice for you has already been expressed in that link, so I encourage you consider all the ideas there. Among other themes, that post also touched on the significant risks associated with online dating. So I'll reiterate this message for the sake of balance - going online to meet women is NOT for everyone, and even when it becomes useful, it should NOT become a crutch.

Additionally, I'll add the following points based on my reading of your post above:
  • Many men claim that modern women are delusional about their value for relationships or even as a person, and I largely agree with this. Yet the same men may overlook their own biases. Some men believe they deserve highly attractive women just because they have seen that they exist (social media, p@@n, etc), they want them (have socio-sexual desire) and they attach internalised values to them (they are young, innocent, trad, etc). This doesn't mean anything when it comes to the "getting", because "wanting" is free.
  • With the above in mind, it's essential to (a) develop highly accurate awareness of your own "husband material value", (b) understand what it truly takes to not just attract but also keep the type of woman you're seeking, and (c) continue doing whatever you reasonably can to improve your value. I've discussed this and more under the subheadings 'It Takes More than Wanting' and 'The Three Questions' here.
  • It makes sense to use Christian-only apps. I encourage you to keep trying. Still, be ready to adapt your approach based on your results. If you aren't making tangible progress after say, another 3 months or so, I would also think about firing up one major secular app (or two max) that are more marketed towards relationships. Ensure to screen really hard, as Bizet suggested here. Personally I had success with Hinge. Though I can't guarantee it'll be appropriate for your area. This is just one example, as there may be other apps out there that could work for you.
  • It's good that you updated your pictures. Seek out feedback on your new pics and profile from someone who knows how to give practical help to you as an individual and genuinely wants you to succeed. Aim to get thoughts from both the male and female perspective. Most women give useless dating advice but with online profiles their input can actually make a big difference. Get ready to recieve challenging feedback. This may be difficult to hear at first but keep in mind that this information could help your prospects in the longer term.
  • Make sure you are doing whatever you can to retain your outward appearance and inward feeling of youth, health, positive energy, and overall vigor. For more on this topic in the context of dating, see here under the heading 'The Options' then the subheading 'Regarding point (b) - staying young'.
  • I know how it feels to start chatting with an attractive woman and it all seems to be going well, then suddenly she ghosts you. Just wait until you start going on first dates. Even if they seem to go really well, you can get ghosted. Then wait until you start dating, meet up regularly, and get told how much she "can't wait to see you!! ❤", etc. You can still get ghosted. Remember the golden rule for in dating online: nothing is promised beyond the present moment. Try to stay focused on the present day at all times and avoid getting attached to any single woman. This may sound like "cold game advice" but even conservative women online will ghost men without hesitation. This is a function of the medium.
  • To assist with steeling yourself mentally, Here's a video to review:

Has this been useful? Let me know. All the best.
 
Last edited:
  • In the eyes of many women in their mid-late 20s, the age around mid-30s is the key time when men change from being "an option" vs "not an option". Why? Because 33 is linked to "a bit past 30", whereas 37 is associated with "almost 40". Consider how your precise age is viewed within this framework.
I have noticed with western women age gap acceptance widens noticeably with age.

For an 18 year old western girl a 22 year old guy is often considered "an older guy".

For women around 23 or 24 the age gap they are willing to accept often stretches to 6 or 7 years (i.e. a guy who is 29 - 31). However a 30 year old western woman is often open to dating a 40 - 45 year old man if he has money and is in good shape.

The problem of course being why would you want a 30 year old woman for anything serious?

This is where overseas comes into it. In poor countries 18 or 19 year old women will happily date a 45 year old man if he is in good shape, has money and has charisma.

The conclusion is obvious. As a middle aged man you really need to head overseas.
 
I have noticed with western women age gap acceptance widens noticeably with age.

For an 18 year old western girl a 22 year old guy is often considered "an older guy".

For women around 23 or 24 the age gap they are willing to accept often stretches to 6 or 7 years (i.e. a guy who is 29 - 31). However a 30 year old western woman is often open to dating a 40 - 45 year old man if he has money and is in good shape.

The problem of course being why would you want a 30 year old woman for anything serious?

This is where overseas comes into it. In poor countries 18 or 19 year old women will happily date a 45 year old man if he is in good shape, has money and has charisma.

The conclusion is obvious. As a middle aged man you really need to head overseas.

A mid 40s man could easily find a woman around 30 (assuming she is single also because of her lack of reasonable prospects) and she will have a few good years of reasonably healthy fertility. He does not need money. She will be starting to feeling slight desperation (30 is a big deal for a lot of women).

Now when you start pushing toward mid 20s female then I think more resources come into play because the girl is less fearful about her future.

It's not a good thing to make 40s men feel hopeless unless they go overseas which is FAR from the truth.
 
It's hard not to get despondent about things sometimes. I am just trying to be comfortable by myself and trust God. When I was younger, I never worried about finding someone, but as I get older, I feel like it will get harder to marry a quality woman. I'm in my mid 30s and feel comfortable I could get a nice 20-something year old woman, but when I turn 40 I feel like I will be "too old" for most of them. Unlike some people on this forum, I think some women who are 30s (especially early 30s) can be decent prospects (some women have trouble finding good men too, and men can be deceptive just like women can) but I don't want to utilize that option until I am older.
Yes, we have to be honest. It changes a lot, even though I don't believe it should, from a social and mental point of view when you go from mid 30s to 40s. The thing that makes me somewhat cynical or think the society or culture is stupid is that you can be on top of your game at mid 30s in the west, good shape, good job, etc and you just won't come across any volume of women that's very attractive relative to your achievements and SMV. So to me even though there is a mental change, it still largely doesn't matter unless there is some way you can actually meet LOTS of women. That's either not easy at all, or takes TONS of time and investment otherwise. When you've already done that in your career and in the gym, it's a stupid thing for you to have to take extra steps when the woman is the one that will benefit from it all. I'm not complaining, seriously, I'm just saying (and of course willing to pay that price, as I have).
  • Well done for getting back out there and trying again after your relationship ended. It can take some time (months to years) to fully recover, so it's good to see you are resilient and trying again.
  • Online dating is tough, so you need to be not just tougher, but also smarter, and this means having a clear, definable strategy.
  • It's encouraging that you seem self-aware and realistic about your dating prospects as it relates to age. Let's be real. Men have a "wall" -- it just doesn't hit as hard or fast as for women. Nowhere is this more evident than online. Compared to avenues that involve in-person interaction, online dating makes age gaps a huge barrier to meeting up. This is because, if a woman sets her limit to just 1 year below your age, you'll NEVER match with her. If you are 35+ let alone 40+, merely matching with attractive women in their early to mid 20s online (assuming they are trad, not gold diggers etc) is going to be highly unlikely.
  • In the eyes of many women in their mid-late 20s, the age around mid-30s is the key time when men change from being "an option" vs "not an option". Why? Because 33 is linked to "a bit past 30", whereas 37 is associated with "almost 40". Consider how your precise age is viewed within this framework.
  • For a man in his mid-late 30s, some women in their late 20s and even early 30s (assuming they haven't gone through a ho3 phase, don't have an attachment disorder etc) can be a suitable prospect for marriage/children. This is because they are likely to be more ready to fully commit, get married, and prepare for having children compared to women in their early 20s or even mid 20s. Note: This is a broad statement about women that does not address the context of a church community, the theoretical ideal age of early-mid 20s for getting together, etc.
You are spot on. You can be a wonderful marriage prospect, though (I know, some might roll their eyes, another internet poster, etc) and just not come across anything remotely highly valuable as a woman though that you'd actually commit to, which is the issue here.
With the above in mind, it's essential to (a) develop highly accurate awareness of your own "husband material value", (b) understand what it truly takes to not just attract but also keep the type of woman you're seeking, and (c) continue doing whatever you reasonably can to improve your value. I've discussed this and more under the subheadings 'It Takes More than Wanting' and 'The Three Questions' here.
Again, I totally agree and I think everyone should read your post 3 times. My experience is such that even if I'm picky, want too much, etc it's hard to even meet a girl who is within 1 point SMV that isn't already old, and at that point, she's not even that same SMV because she's already old and/or with baggage. That's not what marriage is all about per se, but I'm unwilling to do the companion thing until at least 60, lol. I'd literally have to be indifferent entirely about sex to want to just spend time with a woman for no other good reason. Brutally honest, but true.
The problem of course being why would you want a 30 year old woman for anything serious?
It keeps coming back to this, yes. Let's say you are a 6 even, and you're a man at 35. You are going to keep up professionally and have good net worth, making more and being in good shape for at least 15 years. Her attractiveness from 31-35 plummets, literally falls into a crater - and that can be worth it, but only with a trade for that girl's 25 year old self.
This is where overseas comes into it. In poor countries 18 or 19 year old women will happily date a 45 year old man if he is in good shape, has money and has charisma.

The conclusion is obvious. As a middle aged man you really need to head overseas.
This is what I've found because you don't get any relative SMV value in the west, and you pay a TON for a very marginal woman age and looks wise. It really does come down to women needing you, because it's not just a western spoiled thing, it's a western spoiled/tech/fattening thing.
A mid 40s man could easily find a woman around 30 (assuming she is single also because of her lack of reasonable prospects) and she will have a few good years of reasonably healthy fertility.
That is technically true, but I think even 6s in the west are few and far between at this point, and especially post 30.

Now, if you want to have kids and legacy at all costs, you might want to agree to something. I personally don't find that "worth it" but it's a personal decision. I also don't find that just having a family and slaving for their overall provisioning, without getting good treatment from a wife, is worth it these days. I see it a lot where guys don't but they don't complain, because it doesn't matter even if they did. The other part is that all the married people say it's all worth it, etc. The problem is that we would never actually know because they leave this part out: literally no one is going to tell you, for social and ego reasons, that being married/having a family sucks. I'm pretty good with human bias and seeing it or picking it out, and this is a classic example.
 
Has this been useful? Let me know. All the best.
This post (and the other ones you linked to) are definitely helpful, thank you!

I am going to work on my "day game" skills, but for the purpose of finding a wife and not hooking up. I live in the country, where there are some attractive women and nice prospects, but not a lot of single women. I'm thinking of going to a nearby small city and trying it out. I also want to just work on my overall social skills and talk to men and women that I'm not trying to date too. I can be charismatic and outgoing, but I am shy and not good at breaking the ice. I think if I could get better at this, I'd have a lot more options than online dating.

After reading some "field reports," it looks like a fair amount of men haven't had too much trouble getting a woman like 10-12 years younger, so even if it takes me until 39 to get married, I'd be happy with a good woman who is 27-30. Fortunately, I can pass for 5-10 years younger than my actual age, which makes day game a good option compared to online dating when my age is part of the algorithm and is one of the first things women will notice.

I am working on shifting my mentality from "I want to find someone good now before I get too old" to a long-term strategy mainly focused on self-improvement, acquiring wealth, and getting more social exposure, not just for the purpose of meeting women, but to achieve various goals I have and have a better social network in general.
 
So to me even though there is a mental change, it still largely doesn't matter unless there is some way you can actually meet LOTS of women. That's either not easy at all, or takes TONS of time and investment otherwise. When you've already done that in your career and in the gym, it's a stupid thing for you to have to take extra steps when the woman is the one that will benefit from it all. I'm not complaining, seriously, I'm just saying (and of course willing to pay that price, as I have).
I think the "meeting lots of women" is the X factor. Someone could be a great prospect, but if they don't go out and meet people, they won't find anyone. On the other hand, someone who is decent across the board, decent looking, decent personality, with a decent income, might find a good woman (not top tier, but friendly and somewhat cute) to marry if they meet enough women to increase their chances.

I don't like bars and clubs. I don't even really go out to eat much. I've met women at coffee shops, supermarkets, etc., before so that's one option. I am going to look into things like sports/activities, volunteering, and just going out to shop more, thrifting, etc. to hopefully meet someone decent. You're right, it is a big investment in time, but using apps can be just as big of an investment, and more fruitless.

If anyone has good suggestions of places to meet women, I'm all ears.
 
I think the "meeting lots of women" is the X factor. Someone could be a great prospect, but if they don't go out and meet people, they won't find anyone. On the other hand, someone who is decent across the board, decent looking, decent personality, with a decent income, might find a good woman (not top tier, but friendly and somewhat cute) to marry if they meet enough women to increase their chances.

I don't like bars and clubs. I don't even really go out to eat much. I've met women at coffee shops, supermarkets, etc., before so that's one option. I am going to look into things like sports/activities, volunteering, and just going out to shop more, thrifting, etc. to hopefully meet someone decent. You're right, it is a big investment in time, but using apps can be just as big of an investment, and more fruitless.

If anyone has good suggestions of places to meet women, I'm all ears.
Yep, it's definitely an investment. Average guys who have access to a lot women, usually spent a certain amount of time exposing themselves to women.

As for where to meet younger girls. I usually do it via my social circle. I'm a mid 30s guy but have always been on sports teams. As time goes by I'm basically the oldest on the team. Many of my teammates are in their early 20s. We get along really well (I'm not talking about conspiracy theory discussion level chemistry, but good enough for us to be awesome teammates). Obviously, once they realize I'm cool they'll ask if I want to go out with them or come to some friend's BBQ etc.

Another thing I can recommend are beginner's dance courses. Latin dance usually has a broad age spectrum and there's no expectation for you to be coordinated because everyone is a beginner.

In these settings as a financially stable man you stand out because the girl sees she can have fun with you, you fit into her social circle and on top of that you're more mature and better off.

Of course, if you don't enjoy playing sports or dancing, these options aren't for you. But they're just examples. When it comes to dancing, I'm more deliberate. Whereas the basketball stuff is just a natural byproduct of me doing something I genuinely enjoy.
 
I think the "meeting lots of women" is the X factor.

Yep, it's definitely an investment. Average guys who have access to a lot women, usually spent a certain amount of time exposing themselves to women.

It's the absolute key and problem all at the same time. Maybe it's also an era where a lot of guys have done well and can get international attention, but the women are just few and far between, especially due to the small window they have that I will frequently talk about. I saw this reel on IG or youtube somewhere, where a dating coach talks about this with an asian woman. He's like, these are some world class men, they have X, Y, Z but what they don't have is the pure numbers in meeting a variety of women. I know this is a problem for me, because it's also the most obvious one. How many women did I even brush shoulders with this past week? A crazy small number. The problem is that once you've done the actual life work, and no one sells you (the era is a gynocentric one and good women are sparse), you are tired of trying to go out and sell yourself some more, since you aren't the one that needs someone. She is.
 
In reality they are receiving DM's from bots and fillipino virtual assistants who manage their social media profiles. Busy succesfull men are paying a few hundred a month to have their dating app and social media put on auto pilot so they dont have to waste hours everyday talking to women in text or on the phone. The only women who get actual attention from these athletes and celebrities are the ones that make it to the date in person every contact before that is handled by virtual assistants. Of course the average women doesnt know that and they will still put that feather in their hat as a trophy having exchanged text messages with succesfull men.
This kind of set off a lightbulb with me. I am very fussy. I want my next partner to be child free and not a land whale. She can be thicker, cool. But no extreme obesity which seems so common these days. I’m not demanding a virgin trad wife, a few boyfriends in the past is fine, but I just don’t want the town bike. I’ve looked into a matchmaking service to achieve these what would’ve been extremely reasonable goals for a man in his early 30s, once upon a time. However … it would be pricey.

What if I just offered someone a part time job with experience to run my dating app? Get me results, you get a bonus.
 
This is a good video. Lot's of value with illustrations! Gotta love pictures.

Hope some of you find this useful.


Ha! This video is brutal. Hoe Math's diagram is very informative, and it's interesting to hear this woman's take on it. She recognizes it is all true, and is taken by surprise.

To be cynical, I would say that the chart comes down to the old red pill maxim, "A woman would rather be the f*cktoy of a high value man, than the wife of a dutiful beta". The latter part of the video lays this out, that a woman wants a high value man who is a bad boy, and she will choose a low level of commitment with a bad boy over a higher level of commitment with someone that has less of the bad boy vibe.

The lesson of the video is that a woman who can't win the hot billionaire to be monogamous with her should lower her expectations, and accept the best level of dutiful beta that she can actually attract.
 
The lesson of the video is that a woman who can't win the hot billionaire to be monogamous with her should lower her expectations, and accept the best level of dutiful beta that she can actually attract.
Yes but we all know that women are not rational or logical. Its all about whatever makes their vagina tingle no matter how much you beat them over the head with logic and facts. The only way in general that women make wise relationship choices is when their parents choose the men or extreme poverty forces them to choose the right man.
 
I’ve looked into a matchmaking service to achieve these what would’ve been extremely reasonable goals for a man in his early 30s, once upon a time. However … it would be pricey.
At this point in world history, this is only worthwhile in other countries as well due to the fact that you just aren't going to find young women, even if the laws also weren't awful in the anglosphere or similar countries. For example, if you are 40, what are the odds you find a 28 year old woman in the USA. Then she and her friends and family are OK with that? Then the marriage and all of your resources are linked to the law and courts? It's like multiple levels screaming at you to not even bother thinking about spending time and energy to "get married". For the last 10 years (30s to 40s) I didn't meet on girl past my age of 32, and that was only by luck through a common working situation. She was like 27 when I met her, or 28. Then, 1 divorced woman no kids at age 31 when I was just over 40, did little to nothing for me at that age and some baggage, but not a ton. Every other even possible connection or encounter was women 35ish or over, lol - some were nice women but you're just not going to do that as a put together man with a high net worth. It's silly.
Why not just stack some cash and head overseas for a year? You can get a much higher quality woman like this.
And this is the only thing worth it, as AS and I have said for the better part of a year now. A real commitment or marriage for a man who has his shit together, will have a million dollar net worth or more in the next few years, and might have other qualities requires a 10+ year age gap. People can say what they want, but a guy just isn't going to be enticed by anything but youth after he's achieved what he has or has been successful. I think women not understanding this is just their general disinterest in sex, or their lack of confidence being older, related to sex. They want a guy to hang out with socially and his money, but they offer nearly zero in return from what a man would want (sex, family, etc).
I am working on my exit plan. I should by out by 2026.
That's it.
 
I think women not understanding this is just their general disinterest in sex, or their lack of confidence being older, related to sex. They want a guy to hang out with socially and his money, but they offer nearly zero in return from what a man would want (sex, family, etc).
Disagree, I think young women are very interested in sex as much as men are. If they weren't, we wouldn't see so many 25-year-olds with body counts in the hundreds. Or so many cheating wives bored with their pushover husbands.

In fact, their standards for who they sleep with are different and lower than their standards for who they will date. Basically they're just looking for a guy who knows how to stimulate arousal and sexual pleasure, nothing more. But still, they maintain much higher standards for sex than men. Because of their selectivity, it may make them seem more disinterested.

The real problem is women just have absolutely no foresight. In their twenties, they think the party can last forever and they'll find the perfect guy waiting for them at the end of the road, just as soon as they feel like jumping off the hedonistic bandwagon. I don't even think the age gap issue is the main problem, it's just that young women by and large are not interested in a healthy marriage. What does it matter if a man is 25 or 45 if he can't even find any woman under 25 to share his values? It's true, the older guys have the social barrier to overcome, but young guys are not swimming in abundance by any means, and they're usually poor too.
 
Back
Top