How much does it have to do with trust/honesty vs. fear of the stick- unavoidable punishment and ubiquitous cameras and tracking?
The China Thread
- Thread starter God's lonely asperger
- Start date
The "China as a high-trust society' spin is so laughably incorrect that you'd have to wonder if the Changs aren't just making a blatant mockery of their low info pro bono online westoid simps. China is not a high trust society. China is not even a low-trust society either, but a zero-trust society instead. Can't stop wondering how much these foreigners get paid for these videos, bar seems really low these days.
Meanwhile in the real China, far away from slick and high grade staged propaganda videos reality seems a bit less rosy. In the video below a 'high-trust' Chinese senior gets run over by a fellow 'high trust' Chang. The 'high trust' perp than speeds off, obviously high in trust that the matter will be taken care off and his further attendance isn't needed. That's high trust. The senior Chang then lies on the asphalt in agony for minutes, probably high in trust that the ambulance will come soon even though nobody in China calls ambulances for strangers because it means financial liability in case the other 'high trust' Chang victim is, like the majority of Chinese, a brokie.
In the videos dozens if not hundreds of other high trust drivers and pedestrians can be seen walking and driving by. This is because they are so high trust in China's system and their fellow citizens' benevolence - anyone who says otherwise is CIA bytheway. They are also high trust in the victim's physical resilience hence confidently choose to keep high trusting the plan. Whether an ambulance eventually arrived isn't clear, arrival time of first responders in China is extremely unreliable but that's just part and parcel of living in a high trust society .
Did I say China is a high trust society already? The term is suddenly in widespread use by all the sellout Chang whisperers so might as well join in on the bonanza. High trust society!
Another banger from serpentza, this time related to China's crumbling and highly compromised infrastructure. In China on average 30 major bridges collapse a year. Even so the CCP, high in trust as always, hasn't registered a single bridge collapse since 2015, yet in the 2000-2014 timespan 302 major bridge collapses were reported, equalling 22 collapses a year. Since then citizens initiatives from abroad have registered around 3 major bridge collapses every single month.
Like with anything else in China people die regularly in these collapses, yet noone cares and nothing gets done about the near diabolical corruption, shady business practices and inferior building styles causing it. In the video below serpentza and laowhy86 mention the Qinghai tourist ropebridge collapse last month. 5 people died, 11 are missing. In 2024 the same bridge collapsed as well, that time without victims.
High trust!
Some additional collapses
Like with anything else in China people die regularly in these collapses, yet noone cares and nothing gets done about the near diabolical corruption, shady business practices and inferior building styles causing it. In the video below serpentza and laowhy86 mention the Qinghai tourist ropebridge collapse last month. 5 people died, 11 are missing. In 2024 the same bridge collapsed as well, that time without victims.
High trust!
Some additional collapses
A fellow American who lived in Xi'an during the years that I was in Guangzhou, and who was married to a Chinese lady, used to keep this huge stash of pictures of collapsed bridges that he grabbed off social media and found on the Chinese from about 2006-2009.
In Guangzhou, if the bridge doesn't collapse, someone will just throw you off it.
Being forced to behave properly is high-tech slavery.
Yes (I mentioned unavoidable punishment in China), in the West crimes go unpunished despite solid incriminating evidence, and it's common knowledge among the thieves, that's why they're so brazen, again in China you will face harsh consequences and it's a given.
Expectation says a noticeable change occurred after Covid, not that long ago, when the wages were not rising exponentially any more, looks more related to surveillance measures and the introduction/tightening of the social credit system.
Last edited:
Bytheway, on the topic of road safety, here's a chart of deaths per 100 000 people. Compare this to Japan, which is an actual advanced and high trust society.
Now also compare that to Europe. Don't mind the color patterns, China would have been pitch black if on the same graph.
China is third world all the way, and due to certain macro-economic, financial and demographic trajectories will in the next 50 years stay that way. Not a single indicator speaks in the opposite direction. The wumao know this hence why you are currently getting bombarded on whatever platform with these smooth feel good emo- propaganda videos instead.
Last edited:
Although your propaganda is fairly lame, it does work with lower IQ crowds or the rabidly anti-Chinese set that will consume that kind of propaganda at face value.
Here's a basic stat for you: China has built over 900,000 bridges the last few decades.
AI Overview
China has built over 960,000 highway and high-speed railway bridges, making it a global leader in bridge construction. This large number reflects China's commitment to infrastructure development, economic growth, and connecting its vast territory through advanced engineering and project management.
Key Statistics:
- Total Bridges: Over 960,000 bridges have been constructed in China.
- Highway Bridges: The country possesses more than 830,000 highway bridges as of 2017, with an average of approximately 28,000 new highway bridges being built each year from 2007 to 2014, according to ASCE Library.
- High-Speed Railway Bridges: Nearly half of China's high-speed railways are built on bridges, demonstrating a significant portion of the infrastructure being dedicated to this structure type.
- World's Tallest Bridges: China is home to 90% of the world's top 100 tallest bridges in the 21st century, according to 新华网.
Going forward though, I would expect the failure rate in N. America to exceed that of China given the state of disrepair of US infrastructure and its aging.
Report: The U.S. Has Over 47,000 Structurally Deficient Bridges [Infographic]
At the current rate, it would take 80 years to fix all of the structurally deficient bridges across the United States.
www.forbes.com
Video lasts 48 seconds, doesn't show you what took place before or after, just some dude laying down stretching on a crosswalk, has vibes of being staged, and is posted by a 100% China hater channel - likely recipient of the $1.6 BILLION US anti-China propaganda fund?
That is the kind of level of propaganda on that channel from their most recent batch, they show a bunch of Chinese workers taking their midday siesta naps and try to pass that as some kind of a worker holocaust:
Last edited:
So China has road fatalities half as high as those in SE Asia, and a bit higher than those in Poland, Russia or Romania, and that is your proof of China being some kind of a dystopia?
Notice how you have avoided talking about thefts and lack thereof, which was the original subject above. I wonder why? lol.
How about crime rates, let's have a look:
Homicide rate in China 11 times lower than in the US, 4 times lower than in Canada.
Let me help you out a bit LaNegra - this here below is what a low trust society looks like, and this happens every day near Serpentza and C-Milk's US adobes, but they will instead report about a couple of the 960,000 Chinese bridge failures instead, LOL!
What, other than anarchotyranny, can there really be in the 21st century?
I think one factor that might be at work here is their social media and its influence on society, Douyin, Xiaohongshu are chock-full of feel-good stories featuring good samaritans (in part due to state censorship), while in the West TikTok and Insta are a toxic well of narcissism and social dysfunction that demoralizes and brings down society.
This guy asked the same question:
"What's most amazing about this is that China was not always like this. As recently as 20-30 years ago things were not nearly as "safe" as this.
Why it happened is a Ph.D. thesis waiting to be written. How it happened we largely know: what happened in China over the past several decades is well documented and shared on the internet.
Are people just afraid of Chinese police? But China was even more authoritarian 20-30 years ago. Is it the cameras? Then how come that guy on NYC subway killed that Ukrainian refugee all on camera?I don't have the full answer, but I think part of the answer is "social consensus": most of society agreeing on most values.
But you think that just means people are brainwashed? But they were brainwashed even more 30 years ago and yet this did not happen.
And then of course what is the goal? For people to fight each other and live in fear, carrying guns when they go to buy milk and bread? Lots of questions and people just pulling answers from their favorite Freedom(tm) textbook.
To be fair, US and Europe were a bit like this 50 or so years ago, though they are no longer anything like it.
Unchecked immigration? I think that is a part of it. Immigrants do not share local values. A small number of immigrants is probably ok, but too many at once tips the balance.
But even that does not seem to be the complete answer to the question of what it takes to lose it."
Last edited:
A good observation and questioning process so I'm happy to respond to you here.
The emergence of the Middle Class has been driven by lower cost of living & supply side and local Chinese consumer brands. Right now, it is at a stage where costs from these local brands are cheap because they are a couple years new and testing the consumer market. I suspect in a couple of years cost of living would go up as these local brands realize their actual positioning in the market and then wages would need to go up to maintain or increase quality of life. @SpyofMoses - this is to answer your question earlier btw.
You can google Dual Circulation Strategy for more on how they're breaking out of the middle income trap.
There is actually no social credit system in the same way most folks in the west believe it is - rather it is a debt credit system. Its too much effort to respond to every posts and I made a meme mocking that assertion a long time ago but I'm not going to respond to correct to every mention of it like a bot.
So yes, it is more related to an increase in material well being rather than authoritarianism. You also see similar elements of this behavior to other Sino ethnostate societies such as Korea, Japan, Taiwan as long as basic quality of life is met.
Last edited:
Politico: Pentagon plan prioritizes homeland over China threat
Han Feizi: Asia without America, Part 3, Liberal Taiwan in a Realist World.
Asia without America, part 3: liberal Taiwan in a realist world - Asia Times
Mornin' will come, and I'll do what's right Just give me till then to give up this fight And I will give up this fight – Bonnie Raitt This is the thirdasiatimes.com
Han Feizi taking a victory lap and applaud the prioritization back home.
'Skull Chart' math behind Trump’s climbdown on all things China - Asia Times
You used to say live and let live (You know you did, you know you did, you know you did) But if this ever changing world in which we're living Makes you
asiatimes.com
"The US is now reckoning with the “Skull Chart” – a darkly humorous meme passed around on social media. The Skull Chart is a visual representation of Vaclav Havel’s famous observation of China’s explosive growth, “We have not yet had time to be astonished.” Every US versus China chart is now the Skull Chart.
China’s trend lines are merciless. The American populace and institutions are just beginning to reckon with the Skull Chart and its implications. The new National Defense Strategy, if implemented, is surely the correct decision for an overstretched empire, given Skull Chart math.
It is long past time for America to come home, circle wagons, lick wounds and put out domestic dumpster fires. While soldiers patrolling American cities may be dystopian to many, it is hard to deny that vast swathes of urban America could use whatever resources are freed up from overseas military commitments."
Attachments
Here's a proper China story from a man who visited Guangzhou in 2004 and got sick and had to get his appendix removed. I arrived in Guangzhou the next year and everything he has animated and said is familiar to me. I agree with him that the hospitals have improved a lot since then, but like everything in China, they had nowhere to go but up.
Some hospitals are a lot better but, while visiting friends, I saw two very large hospitals visiting friends in Guangzhou (including the "leading" children's hospital in GZ where they were completely unable to help my friend's 4 y.o. with foot and mouth disease) as late as 2018 that were every bit as bad as what is being described here. The other hospital had long corridors with almost no lighting and bathrooms with no soap, and of course no towels.
The red envelopes hong bao he's talking about is the bribe money that you have to give Chinese surgeons prior to the operation or else they will do something to you so that you will understand for the remainder of your life your mistake of not paying the bribe. Part of the context is that in the old days, everyone was paid the same salary and the doctors thought it was unfair that with their training they should get the same compensation as a street sweeper, and I have heard of this happening in other commie cuntries, but as usual, the Chinese take it to the next level, which is probably what happened to one of the guys in the video who could no longer see.
Some hospitals are a lot better but, while visiting friends, I saw two very large hospitals visiting friends in Guangzhou (including the "leading" children's hospital in GZ where they were completely unable to help my friend's 4 y.o. with foot and mouth disease) as late as 2018 that were every bit as bad as what is being described here. The other hospital had long corridors with almost no lighting and bathrooms with no soap, and of course no towels.
The red envelopes hong bao he's talking about is the bribe money that you have to give Chinese surgeons prior to the operation or else they will do something to you so that you will understand for the remainder of your life your mistake of not paying the bribe. Part of the context is that in the old days, everyone was paid the same salary and the doctors thought it was unfair that with their training they should get the same compensation as a street sweeper, and I have heard of this happening in other commie cuntries, but as usual, the Chinese take it to the next level, which is probably what happened to one of the guys in the video who could no longer see.
^Good channel, thanks, the guy has a very good accent, indicative of a full cultural immersion in China. He doesn't come across as a glowie or paid shill, though clearly anti-mainland as most Brits tend to be, is a good writer and has good production values.
The Philippines were one of the richest countries in Asia at one point in the 20th century, so I wouldn't take that for granted. Had China gone liberal, things might have gotten much worse for the average Chinese instead of improving.
That experience of his was from 2004, 21 years ago. If you go another 21 years from then, China was on par with or worse than the Philippines, which were richer than China in the 80s but started tanking under Marcos.
That guy above did a good video about China then and now, vs Britain:
The Philippines were one of the richest countries in Asia at one point in the 20th century, so I wouldn't take that for granted. Had China gone liberal, things might have gotten much worse for the average Chinese instead of improving.
That experience of his was from 2004, 21 years ago. If you go another 21 years from then, China was on par with or worse than the Philippines, which were richer than China in the 80s but started tanking under Marcos.
That guy above did a good video about China then and now, vs Britain:
Last edited:
China is not a high trust society. Turn off all the millions of surveillance cameras and the big brother system and watch how quickly everything will get stolen. China is not Japan. Japanese don't steal because they are honorable. Chinese don't steal because they know the government is watching their every move.
The commie regime in Nepal has just been removed, the Parliament building is on fire just like the residences of the country's top dogs are. The ousted leadership is currently trying to flee the country, possibly for China and the likes, but Kathmandu airport is barely operational and roads are closed
In recent history Nepal has seen a longstanding and brutal Maoist insurgency against the country's Hindu monarchy. In 2008 this resulted in the monarchy being abolished and a de facto commie takeover as the Maoist rebels were on Kathmandu's doorsteps anyway. This insurgency was supported front center and back by the CCP, even though the Changs denied this trying to maintain their 'peaceful dove, non-interventionist do-gooders' BS image. This relation has since been deepened out. The Nepali commies have been ruling with an iron fist ever since despite fake election cycles, and last week the Nepali commies decided to block all Western media platforms on a whim. The subsequent protests were met with heavy machine gun fire from the emboldened and legally untouchable security forces, shoot- to- kill policy.
Today the Nepali commies got thrown in the dustbin of history. Paid China simping self-proclaimed Twitter 'experts' BIG MAD. How all of this pans out is uncertain though, and the geopolitical dynamics might actually not change that much barring a clear improvement of the Indian position. Either way seeing commie flags getting ripped off flagpoles and seeing the filthy rich nepo commie trust fund leeches run for their lives is always a sight to behold. Never mind the cope and seethe to come from the dishonest-to-the-core and paid-to-BS CCP funded pro China commentators, can't wait to see Berletic's shiny bald head as he sobs about 'muh color revolution' and a load of other inflated buzzwords. The Nepali commies, in Lenin's legacy, were also the first Asian country to legalize homo 'marriage'.
socialistchina.org
In recent history Nepal has seen a longstanding and brutal Maoist insurgency against the country's Hindu monarchy. In 2008 this resulted in the monarchy being abolished and a de facto commie takeover as the Maoist rebels were on Kathmandu's doorsteps anyway. This insurgency was supported front center and back by the CCP, even though the Changs denied this trying to maintain their 'peaceful dove, non-interventionist do-gooders' BS image. This relation has since been deepened out. The Nepali commies have been ruling with an iron fist ever since despite fake election cycles, and last week the Nepali commies decided to block all Western media platforms on a whim. The subsequent protests were met with heavy machine gun fire from the emboldened and legally untouchable security forces, shoot- to- kill policy.
Today the Nepali commies got thrown in the dustbin of history. Paid China simping self-proclaimed Twitter 'experts' BIG MAD. How all of this pans out is uncertain though, and the geopolitical dynamics might actually not change that much barring a clear improvement of the Indian position. Either way seeing commie flags getting ripped off flagpoles and seeing the filthy rich nepo commie trust fund leeches run for their lives is always a sight to behold. Never mind the cope and seethe to come from the dishonest-to-the-core and paid-to-BS CCP funded pro China commentators, can't wait to see Berletic's shiny bald head as he sobs about 'muh color revolution' and a load of other inflated buzzwords. The Nepali commies, in Lenin's legacy, were also the first Asian country to legalize homo 'marriage'.
CPC deepens relations with Nepal's communist parties - Friends of Socialist China
Liu Jianchao was recently appointed as the Minister of the International Department of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China, succeeding Song Tao, who completed his term of office. On being informed of his appointment, in a message to a relevant official of the International...
socialistchina.org