I have traveled in those cities, but live in a different top 10 US city that is also very dangerous and I have never been pickpocketed, accosted, or mugged here, but about every third time I rode a bus in Guangzhou someone would try and pick my pocket.Anyone who has lived in cities like NYC, Chicago, LA, SF, Philly etc knows someone who has been mugged, if he wasn't mugged himself. And you are constantly accosted by mentally deranged, aggressive drugged out street people and homeless. It is not that unheard of to come across crime scenes, including murders, if you live in a big American city and go out at night. Most women would be very apprehensive taking the subway alone late at night coming back from downtown.
My point is that China is deceptive. People get mugged there for the first time in their life and then forget about it because the mugger came back an hour after knocking them unconscious and helped them over to the ATM to buy their stuff back.
I talked to foreigners over there all the time who were oblivious to the dangers around them and I think they made up over half of the ex-pats who'd lived there more than two years. They report stuff back to the world and make their videos, whatever, saying that China is much better and much safer than it really is.


